By Karma Martell, President, KarmaCom Inc.
Are you an online marketer involved in search engine optimization? Let me
introduce a new paradigm for you. If I were pitching it to a Hollywood studio
exec (anyone remember Robert Altman's movie, "The Player?"), I would say,
"It's interactive PR meets WOMMA (word of mouth marketing) meets SEO." If it
were a movie title, I would call it "The Godfather," after Michael Corleone's
famous line, "Just when I thought I was out they pull me back in."
Yes, we're going to talk about the advertising dynamic of pull versus push.
Though the terms are bandied around often enough, in SEO, the target prospect
is one step removed. When we optimize searches organically, we are pushing
the search engines, not the search user, to give a web site a top 30 result.
Here's some background:
For a long time, search engine optimization (SEO) was the great equalizer in
online marketing. Search engine success was not determined solely by advertising
clout. Winning the SEO game was determined by the level of the Ebusiness'
awareness as to the importance of search in the overall marketing mix.
Lesser players in medium-large size niches could rub top-30-results shoulders
with their larger counterparts--or even rise head and shoulders above them.
Using marketing know-how and nuance, small fries could win coveted rankings by
optimization of their core message through smart, keyword-rich, SE-friendly
copy, the right site description and title tags, deep linking, etc.
Now the landscape is getting ever-more crowded. While I am still and always will
be a strong advocate of organic (non-paid or "natural") SEO, I have become a
realist in reining in clients' expectations as to what is possible to achieve
in a 12-month period.
The irony is that new sites get indexed faster than ever, but are slower to come
up in the rankings. The proliferation and sophistication of competition, combined
with increasingly larger interactive advertising budgets, makes it very tough to
see quick results. However, tenacious marketers, even those with small budgets,
can still prevail. Organic search success requires patience and a long-term
commitment.
Case in point: as of this writing, a microsite I put up for an independent teen
pop artist and model now ranks #1 on Yahoo, All the Web, Go, Alta Vista, Lycos
and MSN for the term, "cool teenager websites." On Google that phrase holds #10
and #13. The rankings coexist in a universe of over 8 million web citations for
that key phrase. The site also places in the top thirty results for "tower record
music" on several engines. All told the microsite has 55 listings in top 30
positions--including 11 first positions. But that didn't happen in a day. We
have been at this for over two years - and with an indie-sized budget.
Pull: The Shorter - Term Solution
As an advocate and veteran of drive-to-web PR campaigns and strategy, I have
encouraged many clients to include a PR effort as part of their traffic-building
campaign. I call the mix of search-optimized PR feature placements and the
combined buzz factor of online chatter from blogs, social network sites, user-
generated content sites, viral email and offline word of mouth, "Interactive PR."
With this added strategy, clients no longer have to wait for prospects to find
their site as a result of a search query. They are no longer pushing the search
engines; they are pulling in prospects and forcing the search engines to rank
their content based on the sheer amount of activity. Prospects are driven to the
site by contextual features they have heard or seen. The impression is editorial
in nature and seizes a contextual opportunity. It's the equivalent of generating
"brand buzz" so that prospects are proactively looking for your site. That's pull,
literally.
The added benefits are many. The client's web site is pulled into the search engine
radar because of the buzz generated. A proliferation of user queries and incoming
site links from relevant content sources can change the search engine results
landscape fairly quickly. For example, at this writing, Italy's soccer team won
the World Cup three days ago. My Google query today for "Italy wins world cup"
returned 1,220,000 exact results!
Your site or client may not garner millions of queries in a three-day period, but
even a modest integrated marketing PR campaign can still achieve dramatic results.
Community Voice Mail, www.cvm.org, a nonprofit client, saw (exact match) Google
site citations rise to 10,000 in less than three months and then to over 36,000
in less than six months.
When the buzz reaches "critical mass," amazing things can happen. For CVM, the
tipping point occurred when the founder of the world's most-read blog, Boing Boing,
saw a post about CVM in a small-but-important blog he read regularly. Once Boing
Boing wrote about Community Voice Mail, thousands of other bloggers did too. The
critical mass occurred on Christmas week, in the midst of a holiday Ecard
fundraiser my agency created for CVM. The bottom line: the ROI-driven integrated
campaign resulted in helping the charity break all previous records for individual
donations within a given year--and by a huge margin.
Think about how you can create brand evangelists to help pull your site into the
search engine top 10 list. Magic? Science? It's a little of both and none of
either. One thing is for sure: Creativity still pays off!
A New York City agency and consultancy bridging online, multimedia and
traditional marketing, advertising, branding and public relations,
KarmaCom Inc. was founded by marketing, public relations, branding, and
business development expert Karma Martell. Visit her website at
http://www.karmacom.com/.
return to index
|